Andre Bermon –
Businesses say they were caught off guard by the city’s recent extension of no-stopping laws on Queen Street East. Effective as early as May 9, signs along Queen from River to Church Streets banned stopping from 7 a.m. to 7 p.m., Monday to Sunday.
However, business backlash prompted city staff to back peddle and reinstate paid parking on Queen East from 11 a.m. to 2 p.m., every day.
The new parking rules are intended to facilitate transit and traffic flow away from a major watermain replacement and streetcar track renewal project at King Street East and Church Street. According to the city, the infrastructure work will continue until late August.
Business owners who spoke to the bridge a ll s aid t hey r eceived no advance notice of the changes. The TTC issued a flyer on May 8, just a day before the new rules took effect, but only a few owners claimed they had received it.
They said the new no-stopping rule has hurt business on Queen East by restricting loading and delivery times and limiting parking for customers and employees.
Retail shop proprietor Lee B. Johnson said he learned about the new no stopping zone after receiving a $135 ticket outside his shop near Queen and Sherbourne Streets. Johnson says he didn’t receive the TTC flyer or any prior consultation, calling the experience of discovering the new rules by a traffic fine “shameless.”
Further east, Samuel Mandrozos, who runs a U-Haul dealership near Parliament Street, uses the curb lane extensively to park his trucks. He was beside himself at the change.
“If [the city] was going to crush my business, at least tell me about it so I can make alternative plans,” said Mandrozos. He suggested additional exemptions, such as reduced no-stopping hours on weekends, to help alleviate pressure on local businesses.
“Why seven days a week?” said Mandrozos. “Weekend traffic in this area is pretty much dead.”
In a report to Community Council on February 20, transportation services listed “transit priority measures” to support streetcar services during infrastructure improvements at King and Church.
One proposal was to limit curb lane parking on Queen East. The report said parking adjacent to a streetcar lane results in “more general traffic” and is worsened by parking vehicles blocking streetcars.
The staff report said the increased streetcar service from seven to 25 streetcars per hour per direction under the previous no-stopping rules – 7 a.m. to 9 a.m. westbound and 4 p.m. to 7 p.m. eastbound, Monday to Friday – would not suffice.
Therefore, it suggested removing on-street parking and implementing no-stopping zones “will result in an improvement to both transit and general traffic, as there is no longer any impact associated with parked or parking vehicles.”
The report said local area councillors and business improvement areas (BIAs) were consulted in the weeks before community council met on February 20. According to a city spokesperson, Ward 13 Toronto Centre Councillor Chris Moise was contacted on January 22 to discuss traffic plans during the King/Church intersection construction.
Several residents’ associations were contacted on February 5, including the Corktown Residents and Business Association (CRBA), which represents Queen East from Parliament to River Street.
Both the report and the city spokesperson did not mention reaching out to individual businesses.
In an emailed statement to the bridge, Councillor Moise said in response to complaints from business owners, “I have reached out to staff at Transportation Services and the TTC, and they have agreed to reinstate parking between 11 a.m. and 2 p.m. along Queen Street East for the duration of the watermain and track replacement at King Street East and Church Street…
“I am also asking that steps be taken to try and ensure this, and future work is properly communicated to impacted businesses well before construction begins.”
Moise added, “I hope that bringing back three hours of parking will provide some needed relief to business owners and will help minimize that disruption.”
1 Comment
View from the west end…our community traffic patterns are being upended to encourage more easy-west cycle lanes on neighbourhood street. As a result drivers will lose 2 of 3 egress points from our neighbourhood. It means way increased traffic on Sorauren Ave. And we are concerned about safety if there is an emergency evacuation, what with 2 exit routes eliminated. Despite an excellent written community submission and several residents’ verbal presentation, our Councillor diminished concerns and the motion was passed with nary a vote against. So frustrating. Makes one wonder whose best interest the council has in mind…